Thursday, March 6, 2008

Live music on campus, nobody cares

Photo by Ryan Bennie Lee3/7/08

By Matt Vercillo
Critic Staff


Friday, Feb. 16 the Lyndon State student center was host to several live bands.

The event, which was originally advertised as four bands in one night, was free so it became the perfect opportunity for a review. The poster that I saw hanging in the hallway earlier that day had assured me of a few simple facts. First it was four bands, one night. Second, it started at 8:00 p.m. So, as I walked into the building around 7:50p.m., I was quite surprised to hear that the show had already started. I was late, but it was no fault of mine. I guess a fifth band got tacked on at the last minute, making it five bands and beginning at 7:30 p.m. Well, I grabbed myself a chair and took in what I could of the first band finishing up their set with a cover of Skynard’s “simple man” and an interesting version of “Fuel” by Metallica with an Eminem’s “lose yourself” tacked onto the beginning.

At this point I was still more or less trying to take in the scene. The place seemed packed. I began thinking about what a great turn out it had been. All of the tables were full and there were about 20 or 30 people standing around in front stage. The second band took about a half an hour to set up which left me to take the atmosphere in a little more.

I was beginning to feel al little uncomfortable. The turnout was good, that is to say there were a bunch of kids there. However, the more I looked around the more I started noticing things. Why were all their pants so tight? Why were these chicks so skinny? What is with that dude in the capri pants over there? Why is everyone giggling and standing in small, cliquish circles? Then, all at once it dawned on me. They actually were kids. High School students. I was really starting to get p****d off.

The next band finally began playing and distracted me from these observations for a bit. The next band took the stage and I was happy that at least they were playing original tunes. They were called Catamaran, and they played songs with a bit of surf-punk indie vibe to them. They played a half hour set, which turned out to be pretty much the format for all the acts.

Then something happened. The crowd started getting really worked up and excited. I noticed more and more empty energy drinks on the tables and more and more chattering shrieks of 15 year-old girls with braces and neon hair. I was beginning to become less than impressed with this whole event. There were maybe a handful of semi-recognizable strangers dotted around that I could picture going to LSC, but the rest were clearly not students here.

Without announcing their name, the third band began whaling away an obnoxious and distorted brand of hardcore metal, with the vocalist simply screaming into the microphone as horridly as he possible could. The less and less impressed I became of the situation, the more and more the crown seemed to dig what was going on. I was beginning to think this would be a waste of a Friday night.

The fourth came on and I immediately recognized them as the idiots who had propped the door next to my table open for twenty minutes while they carried their equipment in. It was freezing outside, so these guys started off on the wrong foot with me. They announced themselves as Astrada, from Manchester, N.H. Although the crowd seemed pretty much super pumped on these guys, I was failing to see the difference from the last band. It sounded exactly the same.

That pretty much seemed to be the theme from that point on as the next band, Our Drowning City, also sucked. They sounded exactly like Astrada, somebody growling into the mic with heavily distorted guitars. Three awful bands in a row was too much for me to handle and I left before the end of Our Drowning City’s set. I walked out wondering at what point music simply becomes noise.

5 comments:

imallhis6807 said...

This truly is one of the worst articles i have ever read. The author of this article clearly doesn't understand the many levels of ignorance he is showing. Everyone's opinion should be recognized but he is not only showing his own opinion of the show, but is falling off topic completely. He is not putting his full focus on the show, but also attacking the style of the people that attended, and their ages.
The author stated in his article that "the crowd started to get really worked up". Wouldn't that be a sign that he was the one that was out of place? It not once said anywhere that this show was directed towards a specific age group, or a specific style of clothing. If he felt "uncomfortable" as he stated, he should have just left the show, but instead continued to sit next to the open door to find more to complain about.
The author also said that the music was just noise, but if he were to look at it from a true musician's point of view, he would have seen it in different ways and would have focused completely on the music. this is proof that this person doesn't understand music or the many different forms it has. I'm sure that the way he described the music would have put a smile on any metal musician's face because they know that it is an art form and they are capable of showing it to the world, and even people who might not know about or understand it.
Not only was this author's criticism off topic and opinion based, it was also ill-written. Using language like "p***** off" and "sucked" are not appropriate for a public article. It was not professional especially from a 'college author' who is attacking the younger high school students and who's writing distinctly shows lack of understanding for the event. A prime example of the latter is how the author mentioned a specific band in the article. It was not "Our Drowning City" but "This Drowning City” that performed. If a critic is going to openly criticize an event, they should have their facts straight. Furthermore, if he wanted to say they "sucked" he should at least get the name correct.
I will be a freshman at LSC in the fall and this truly is not what i was expecting to find from a member of this college in particular. i expected professional, well written work, and i don't see that in this article.
In conclusion, this entire article was off topic, unprofessional, and just wrong. an opinion is one thing but tearing apart a type of music and lifestyle is another. this article is words of complaint, whining, and proof that this author's intelligence level is not suitable to write an article of this sort.
Tasha, attendee of the show, friend of Shipwrecked Smiles and all bands like them; also a proud graduating student of LI.

Keith Whitcomb Jr. said...

I feel it should go on the record that Matt Vercillo was writing as an opinion columnist. As such, whatever he states is his opinion and his opinion only.

I aplogize if it was taken to be a news article.

The Critic also prides itself on allowing its opinion columnists to say what they feel in whatever manner they would like (within the bounds of good taste).

whats_wrong_with_a_lil_humor? said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
whats_wrong_with_a_lil_humor? said...

i agree with Tasha here.. i was too an attendee at the show. As well, a friends of shipwrecked smiles.. i belive that this article is not only arragent but extremely distasteful... i just happen to be one of those highschool students in tight pants and "neon hair". I find it extremely insulting to be critisized by a person who knows nothing about the music... I find it wrong that this guy would sit and watch a show that he has no interest in. Its just something to complain about. If this is the kind of people that are in your collage, i have my doughts im going to be applying there.
Thank you for a good laugh at todays critics,
Your reader, Le Ann

smirfy said...

ok, I signed up for a google account just to say it seems liek the norm that LSC commonly sinks to. I graduated about 4 yrs ago, not in the area since then, and am sorry for friends/family that attend as they really get nothing different than any other HS kid checkn out the grounds.
In 3 years time, LSC hosted "They might be Giants" and "Our Lady peace" and "American HiFi" and had great social events. I've not heard of any popular bands (of current day n age) to pop by.
The last year I attended LSC was filled with only drag time, the need to get away. Nothing kept me there nor sparked my interest to drive 12 miles back for entertainment. I began to see more and more HS directed entertainment. True many freshmen in college were HS, but dont forget many freshmen HS students were in 8th grade previously.
The people that attended dont surprise me, at all. The author kicked the article just right in my opinion, it seemed lowsey.
Someone had to sit next to a door, someone had to get a glimps of the area n scope it out. Otherwise, only a neon pink teeny bopper would be sreading the word of this kind of event "its like so way"
one last thing for imallhis-boy
doesnt matter at all if someone gets the name correct, ppl build their career in music by performing WELL.
I commend those for speaking their opinion, especially if it speaks the minds of others and what they've seen happen before.
Nick H
VT native and escapee